Free · No signup

CRM Comparison Scorecard

Score four CRM products using weighted criteria and get an instant, transparent result.

Your inputs stay on this device.This tool runs in your browser. Northstar Select does not receive the values you enter.

Criterion / weight
Adoption %	/ 5	/ 5	/ 5	/ 5
Five-user cost %	/ 5	/ 5	/ 5	/ 5
Automation %	/ 5	/ 5	/ 5	/ 5
Reporting %	/ 5	/ 5	/ 5	/ 5
Integrations %	/ 5	/ 5	/ 5	/ 5
Portability %	/ 5	/ 5	/ 5	/ 5

Highest weighted score:

A score is only as useful as the evidence behind each rating. Record test notes, official limits, and current prices before making a purchase.

Embed this CRM comparison scorecard

Add the interactive scorecard to a CRM comparison, consultant resource, or buying course. The responsive code validates the source before resizing, and the required attribution gives readers the full version and methodology.

Responsive embed code

<iframe id="northstar-crm-comparison-scorecard" src="https://riaselect.com/tools/embed/crm-comparison-scorecard/?utm_source=publisher_embed&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_campaign=free_crm_tools&amp;utm_content=comparison_scorecard" title="CRM Comparison Scorecard" width="100%" height="950" loading="lazy" style="border:0;border-radius:12px;min-height:720px"></iframe><script>(function(){var f=document.getElementById('northstar-crm-comparison-scorecard');if(!f)return;window.addEventListener('message',function(e){if(e.origin!=='https://riaselect.com'||e.source!==f.contentWindow||!e.data||e.data.type!=='northstar-embed-resize'||e.data.embed!=='crm-comparison-scorecard')return;var h=Math.max(720,Math.min(1700,Number(e.data.height)||950));f.style.height=h+'px';});})();</script>

Publisher instructions

How to compare CRM vendors with a weighted scorecard

Name each shortlisted CRM and assign weights before entering scores. A weight represents business importance; a score represents how well the product met the documented requirement. Keeping those concepts separate prevents a polished demonstration from making every feature appear equally valuable.

Score evidence, not promises

Use a consistent scale. A high score should require a completed acceptance test and confirmation that the capability is included in the quoted plan. Reduce the score when a requirement depends on custom development, an untested integration, a higher tier, or recurring manual work.

Review the result for hidden constraints

The highest weighted total is a decision aid, not an automatic winner. Check security, contract terms, data portability, implementation risk, user adoption, and total annual cost separately. A product that fails a mandatory requirement should not win because of optional features.

Export the scorecard with the requirement definitions, evidence links, trial date, evaluator names, and vendor quotes. If the team changes a weight after seeing the result, record why.

Frequently asked questions

How should CRM criteria be weighted?

Assign larger weights to requirements that affect critical workflows, controls, adoption, or measurable business outcomes. Set weights before vendor scoring.

What scoring scale should I use?

A simple consistent scale works best. Define what each number means and require evidence for high scores so different evaluators can reproduce the result.

Should price be part of the weighted score?

It can be, but also compare first-year and recurring cost separately. A weighted feature score can hide contract, implementation, and affordability constraints.